I thought I might make a short list of the problems with the Georgia Aquarium’s application to import beluga whales from Russia; issues that might indicate topics on which the Georgia Aquarium isn’t exactly expert.
Education: As Dr. Lori Marino has written, the Georgia Aquarium does not understand that for education to be valid, it must be both accurate and objectively demonstrated to have educational impact. As she explains, the Georgia Aquarium’s program does not meet either threshold. In contrast to some of the testimony in D.C. last week, while a visit to the beluga tank may assist middle school teachers in holding their students’ attention and inspiring a better essay, the increased enthusiasm for a day trip does not outweigh the cost to the captive whale OR of the negative ethical lesson to which the student was just unwittingly exposed. Apparently the Georgia Aquarium does not understand this.
Conservation: Dr. Naomi Rose, of Humane Society International, has pointed out that it is nearly impossible to conceive of any valid study on a captive beluga whale which might indicate how, for instance, climate change might impact the wild beluga population. Yet the Georgia Aquarium seems to think it can, as did Debborah Colbert from the Association of Zoos and Aquariums and Chair of an International Marine Animal Trainers Association committee, who testified in favor of the permit last Friday. The studies, in evaluating the impacts on the wild beluga whale population by such warming and changing environments would ask questions like: Will the whales seek different prey? Move to a different basin? Spend more time in deep water? Less time? Reform into superpods? Break into smaller pod units? I think you can see that none of these questions can be answered in the concrete tank at the Georgia Aquarium. But this, too, seems to escape their comprehension.
Life Expectancy: Whale and Dolphin Conservation and its campaigns manager, Courtney Vail, know that the life expectancy of the beluga whale in captivity and “‘on display’ will probably be a short one. Belugas in the wild can live up to 50 or 60 years. In captivity, they rarely live beyond 30 and frequently do not pass 25.” Another fact of which the Georgia Aquarium seems to be unaware. Or at least one would hope.
Transport/Noise: Bill Rossiter, of Cetacean Society International, has noted that the transport of the dolphins can present noise levels that are within the hearing range of the beluga far in excess of those safe for even humans. For creatures who survive by using echolocation, sitting on a tarmac at these noise levels, as well as being transported for thousands of miles in aircraft that exceed acceptable noise levels for U.S. air space, is clearly something to which a beluga whale should not be exposed. Yet another fact that the Georgia Aquarium appears to not know.
But this short list would not be complete without one last fact. It appears that the Georgia Aquarium may also be, shall we say, geographically-challenged. So maybe, just maybe, they don’t quite know where the 18 beluga whales are coming from, which might get them a pass on the transport issues. The Georgia Aquarium, ever helpful as it cruises the individuals on Facebook, gave its recommendation to a query:
Maybe the Georgia Aquarium thinks they are “importing” the beluga whales from Russia, Ohio via Athens, Kentucky. Hell, that makes as much sense as justifying ripping wild beluga whale communities apart and taking them out of the ocean to study – IN A CONCRETE TANK – the impacts of climate change. Jus’ sayin’.
I hope that poor guy doesn’t listen to travel or route advice from the Georgia Aquarium. I hope NOAA doesn’t either. Tell NOAA that you oppose the beluga import. The links above will give you all the understanding you need for your comment. And some of the understanding the Georgia Aquarium needs to end this atrocity.